Tools

Hire, agency or do it yourself?

A marketing hire, an agency and your own evenings, side by side as yearly costs.

For owners deciding whether to take on a marketing person, pay an agency or keep doing it in the evenings, who want the whole cost of each route on one page before they choose.

Hire, agency or do it yourself? · Estimatesfigures updated October 2026

Your figures

If you are not VAT registered, fees cost you their full price including VAT, so the agency and part-time lines add VAT at 20%.

The salary you would advertise. The default is a placeholder, not a market rate: check local adverts for the role you have in mind.

A recruiter's fee or job board costs. Counted in the first year only.

Laptop, software, subscriptions and any training, as you would pay for them.

Time spent briefing, checking work and one-to-ones. A new hire usually needs more in the first months.

The monthly fee on the proposal, before VAT. Leave out ad spend: you pay that whichever route you choose. The default is a placeholder, not a quote.

Briefings, approvals, reading reports and chasing.

The hours you put in now, or would need to. Count evenings.

Design, email, scheduling and ad tools you pay for yourself.

What you would charge a customer for an hour, or your real hourly rate from the owner's hour calculator.

Result

£46,903first yearA marketing hire, first year, all in
Doing it yourself costs least

In its first year a hire costs about £46,903: £32,000 salary, £4,823 of employer National Insurance and pension, £4,000 to recruit, £2,400 for tools and £3,680 of your own time. An agency comes to £27,680 a year with your time counted, and doing it yourself £15,320, of which £14,720 is your own 368 hours. Our Part-Time Marketing Director, £1,500 a month + VAT (£1,800 in total), comes to £19,840 a year with your time counted. On these figures doing it yourself costs least.

MeasureFigure
Doing it yourself, per year, mostly your time£15,320
Our Part-Time Marketing Director, per year, with your time£19,840
The published price behind that linePart-Time Marketing Director, £1,500 a month + VAT (£1,800 in total)
Lowest cost route on these figuresDoing it yourself, £15,320 a year
Part-time director against the lowest cost route (per year)£4,520
A marketing hire, each year after the first£42,903
Employer National Insurance and pension on top of salary£4,823
Your hours a year doing it yourself368
An agency, per year, with your time£27,680
Yearly cost by route: Hire, first year £46,903, Agency £27,680, Do it yourself £15,320, Our part-time director, with your time £19,840.Hire, first year £46,903Agency £27,680Do it yourself £15,320, lowestOur part-time director, with your time £19,840
Email me this result

How this is worked out

A hire's first year is salary, plus employer National Insurance at 15% of salary above £5,000 a year, plus an employer pension of 3% of salary between £6,240 and £50,270 a year, plus tools, plus recruitment, plus your own hours managing them valued at your hourly worth. The rates are for 2026 to 2027 (GOV.UK, Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027, updated 1 September 2026; GOV.UK automatic enrolment threshold review, 18 December 2025; The Pensions Regulator) and every one is an editable assumption.

What the hire line leaves out: holiday cover, sick pay, a desk, notice periods, and Employment Allowance, which can reduce the National Insurance line if you have room left in it. Pension is counted whenever salary is above £6,240, although a hire earning under £10,000 a year is not enrolled automatically (The Pensions Regulator, earnings thresholds for 2026 to 2027, read 10 October 2026).

An agency is its monthly fee for twelve months plus your hours briefing and checking it. Doing it yourself is your tools plus your hours. Ad spend is left out of every route, because you pay it whichever you choose. If you are not VAT registered, the agency and part-time fees include VAT at 20%, because that is what they cost you.

Your hours are valued at what an hour of your time is worth. The fairest figure is what you would earn doing paid work in that hour; the owner's hour calculator gives your real hourly rate if you would rather use that.

The part-time line is our published price for one day a month of senior time, with a three-month minimum and then rolling on 30 days' notice, and we take two such clients at a time. It is shown for comparison and never counted as the lowest cost route. The tool compares cost, not output: a full-time hire gives you most of a working week, an agency the hours in its proposal, and a part-time director one senior day a month plus answers in between.

Assumptions, yours to change

Fifty-two less the holidays you take. Used for every route's hours.

Monthly sessions and replies. Our part-time marketing director takes one day a month of our time; this is the time it takes of yours.

15% on pay above the threshold for 2026 to 2027 (GOV.UK, Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027, updated 1 September 2026). If you claim Employment Allowance and have room left in it, set this to 0.

£5,000 a year for 2026 to 2027 (GOV.UK, Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027, updated 1 September 2026).

The legal minimum employer contribution is 3% of qualifying earnings (The Pensions Regulator, read 10 October 2026). Enter more if you pay more.

£6,240 a year for 2026 to 2027 (GOV.UK review of the automatic enrolment thresholds, 18 December 2025).

£50,270 a year for 2026 to 2027 (GOV.UK review of the automatic enrolment thresholds, 18 December 2025).

What to do with the number

01 / 03

Doing it yourself costs least in cash, but 368 hours a year is time out of your week, and it only works if those hours happen every week, not when the diary is quiet.

Doing it yourself costs least

02 / 03

Spend the hours on the two channels that bring work in and drop the rest: two done every week will do more than ten done when there is time.

03 / 03

A Growth Review, £600 + VAT (£720 in total), gives you a one-page plan for those hours; a Sounding Board, £500 a month + VAT (£600 in total), keeps it on track each month.

Email me this result

Optional. We will send the figures above with a short written reading within one working day: what we would check first, what a fix would need to recover to pay back, and whether it is worth a call. Nothing else follows, and nothing about your numbers leaves this page unless you send it.

Hire, agency or do it yourself?. DeeZee, . Share link: https://deezee.uk/tools/hire-or-agency